Hammonton, NJ, Pie Shop Named Best in New Jersey

If you don't like pie, then I simply don't know what to tell you.

A great pie is almost universally beloved. That being said, it's almost impossible to come to an agreement with another person over which pie is considered the best. Even if you find common ground on your favorite type of pie you'll almost never agree on which pie shop makes the best pie in the area.

I'm a big fan of a key lime pie, a peach pie, and an apple pie!

Get our free mobile app

Well, the people at 24/7 Wall St., did their best to settle that very debate across the country, and a pie shop in Hammonton happened to make their list as the very best in the entire state of New Jersey.

Now we all know the term "best" is subjective, so here's what they did to figure it out: 24/7 used reviews and rankings on a wide range of websites, including Yelp, Taste of Home, Thrillist, Food Network, Spoon University, and The Daily Meal, as well as numerous local and regional sites. 

When it was all said and done, it was determined that Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Café is the best pie shop in the State!

Per Google, Penza's Pies is described as:

"A family run bakery, cafe, farm, and special event venue made famous for Evelyn Penza's award-winning homemade pies. Featured on the Food Network, in New York Times, and publications around the region, Evelyn's creations are delicious and memorable. In 2022, Red Barn Farms began an annual Fall Fest and Giant Corn Maze, a fun family-friendly outdoor festival encompassing a huge 7 acre corn maze, hayrides, pumpkin painting, and other events."

So what do the people at 24/7 Wall St. recommend when you get there?

The Pineapple ricotta.

So I know what you are asking, where is this place? 391 US-206 in Hammonton. they are open Tuesday through Sunday: 8am – 5pm and closed on Monday's.

Note: They will be closed from Monday, August 21st through Friday, August. 25th.

Enjoy the pie!